All Posts
Deepali's site
EliteEdge
Newsletterby
CommunityEliteEdge+

The Elite Edge: 💰 Your Raise Was Decided in a Room You'll Never Enter 🚪

Doing The Research For You.

Elite Edge | Vol 2 Week 46

🔥 The Meeting About You, Without You

Last week, I told you most self-reviews end up in a virtual trash can. This week, I'm taking you into the room where that happens.

Somewhere in the next few weeks, a group of managers will sit in a conference room (or on a Zoom with cameras off) with a spreadsheet. Your name is on it.

They'll go row by row. Someone will say, "She had a great year." Someone else will say, "Did she, though? I didn't see much from her." Your manager will have about 90 seconds to defend you. Then they'll move to the next name.

That's calibration. It's where ratings get adjusted, bonus pools get split and raises get locked. And you're not invited.

Here's the hard truth: the people who walk out with the biggest numbers aren't always the best performers. They're the ones whose managers walked in with the best ammunition.

And this year, the pot is small.

📊 The Breakdown: The 2027 Pay Math Nobody Explains

Let me show you what your manager is working with.

  • Merit budgets are flat. Employers plan average merit increases of 3.2% and total increases of 3.5% for 2027, according to Mercer's survey of 1,001 U.S. organizations. That's roughly where it's been for four years straight.

  • The "everyone gets something" raise is fading. Only 32% of employers plan across-the-board increases in 2027, down from 36% in 2026, per Payscale. More of the pool is going to whoever gets rated highest.

  • The gap between "solid" and "star" is smaller than you think. In Salary.com's example, a high performer on $75,000 gets 5.5% and a solid performer gets 3.0%. That's a difference of about $72 per paycheck.

  • Promotions are getting rarer. Employers expect to promote about 8.4% of their workforce in 2027, down from 9.9% in 2025.

  • But the year doesn't end in December. 64% of organizations say they have given or will give off-cycle adjustments in 2027.

So here's what that means for you.

What gets decided in the room

What you control before it

Your rating

Debated, compared, sometimes "forced" to fit a curve

The evidence your manager carries in

Your merit increase

Set by your rating and a thin pool

Whether you're the name they fight for

Your bonus

Split from a fixed pot, team by team

How visible your impact was to other managers

Your promotion

Usually pre-decided months earlier

Whether anyone besides your boss can vouch for you

Your flight risk

Quietly discussed

Whether the market knows your name

Look at that last row. Salary.com's own report says merit math alone can't reward top people, and it lists flight risk and market positioning as factors that should count. Translation: the person with options gets paid. The person who seems happy to stay gets 3%.

🛠️ The Toolkit: Win Calibration From Outside the Room

Before calibration: arm your advocate.

  1. Send your manager a one-page "advocate brief." Not your self-review. A short note with your three biggest wins (in numbers), one line on scope you took on, and one line on what you want next year. Make it easy to read out loud in 90 seconds.

  2. Get a second voice. Calibration punishes people only one manager knows. Ask one leader outside your team, someone you helped this year, to mention your work to your manager or skip-level before the meeting.

  3. Ask the timing question. "When do calibrations happen, and is there anything you need from me before then?" Most people never ask. The ones who do get remembered.

  4. Don't go quiet in November. Recency bias is real. A visible win in the next three weeks counts more than a quiet one in March.

After calibration: if the number disappoints.

  1. Don't react in the meeting. Say, "Thank you. I want to take some time to think about this. Can we pick it back up next week?" Then leave.

  2. Ask for the gap, not the reason. "What would I have needed to do to be rated one level higher?" Write down the answer. That's your 2027 contract.

  3. Ask about off-cycle. "If I deliver X by Q2, can we revisit compensation then rather than waiting a full year?" Most companies do off-cycle adjustments. Few employees ask for them.

  4. Negotiate what isn't salary. Title, scope, a stretch project, training budget, a flexible schedule. When the cash pool is thin, these are often easier to give.

  5. Benchmark yourself. If you're consistently rated well and still paid below market, the conversation is no longer with your manager. It's with the market.

Try this prompt this week: "Here are my three biggest wins this year: [paste them]. Turn them into a 150-word advocate brief my manager can read out loud in a calibration meeting. Lead with numbers, name who benefited, and end with one sentence on what I want to own next year."

🎯 The Toolkit: If You're the Manager in the Room

  1. Walk in with evidence, not adjectives. "She's great" loses to "She cut onboarding time in half." Every time.

  2. Know your top two names and fight for them. A thin pool spread evenly rewards no one. Decide who you'll go to the wall for.

  3. Watch for the quiet ones. Calibration rewards visibility. The people who don't self-promote need you to do it for them.

  4. Tell people the truth afterward. If the budget was tight, say so. A hard number delivered honestly beats a vague one delivered nervously.

My advice to everyone: you will never be in that room. But your words can be. Write them so your manager can say them out loud, and give them a reason to say them loudly.

📚What I Read This Week…

Something a little different —

My friend Laszlo has been a Chief Data and AI Officer, so I pay attention when he shares where he’d actually tell his friends to work.

His list has three things I look for, too. Talented people you can learn from, a culture you’d want to be part of, and ambitious work that can accelerate your career.

And yes, there’s room for you at these companies even if you don’t consider yourself a “techie.”

Check out his list 👇

🎙️What I Listened to This Week… (Podcasts)

🎙️ You’ve read the headlines over the weekend about Jensen Huang and Nvidia…and we can’t stop talking about it.

Until next week,

You’ve got the Edge. Now sharpen it.

Until next week,


Your Elite Recruiter
Doing the research so you don’t have to.

THE ROOM IS OFFICIALLY OPEN! 🎉

✨ WELCOME TO ELITE EDGE+ ✨

Your manager has 90 seconds. Make them count.

Inside Elite Edge+, we're doing calibration season together. Members get our advocate brief template, my negotiation playbooks for the "disappointing number" conversation, and live sessions where I walk through exactly what happens in the room, from someone who has sat in hundreds of them.

And if your number comes back low? Bring it to office hours. We'll script your next conversation together, whether that's an off-cycle ask, a scope negotiation or a quiet look at the market. The pay pool is thin this year. Don't walk into it alone.

Welcome to Elite Edge+, a membership community where we take career advice and put it into action.

I created Elite Edge+ to bring you closer to the people, resources, and guidance that can help you move your career forward.

My team and I want to be here for every season of your career. We hope you’ll join us!

Membership details and Founding Member pricing below. 👇

In partnership with

10 Stocks Built for Growth and Income

There’s still room for growth in the market in 2026, and the all-new 10 Best Stocks to Own: Fall 2026 list is built for balance and upside.

Inside, you’ll find reliable dividend growers built to generate income...

Plus high-growth names positioned to benefit from some of the market’s biggest trends.

From AI infrastructure and energy to consumer growth and capital returns, these 10 stocks offer different ways to pursue opportunity this fall.

You don’t have to choose between income and growth.

See the 10 stocks positioned to offer both and get the full report while it’s still free.

🌟 About Me 🤝🏻

🎥  FOLLOW ME

🔥 ELITE RECRUITER ON THE MARCH TO 1 MILLION 🚀

We’re almost there! If you’ve found this newsletter useful, help me scale it:
Share, forward, comment, or repost. Every action gets us one step closer.

Instagram Reel

Feedback is a Gift

I would love to know what you thought of this newsletter and any feedback you have for me. Do you have a favorite part? Wish I would add something? Felt confused? Please reply and share your thoughts!

The Elite Edge Newsletter

Deepali VyasBy Deepali Vyas — The Elite Recruiter

Get an edge for your next pivot, promotion, or career move with curated advice, best practices, and resources to rise above the competition in November 2026.

EliteEdge+Want more than the newsletter? Members get every live webinar, a $99 coaching credit each month, and the private community. Founding members add the full playbook library.
Avatar 1Avatar 2Avatar 3Avatar 4Avatar 5
Learn more →